Save
This shrimp cocktail recipe delivers juicy seafood and zesty homemade sauce with hardly any fuss—it is my default appetizer for gatherings because it is always a crowd-pleaser and takes minimal time to pull together
The vibrant color and tangy snap of this dish got me hooked as a kid at family get-togethers and now I whip it up every time my friends come by unexpectedly
Ingredients
- Large shrimp: make the star of this recipe look and taste luxurious look for firm shrimp with a mild briny scent at the seafood counter
- Lemon: infuses the cooking water with freshness and makes a lively garnish
- Salt: enhances the shrimp’s natural flavor
- Black peppercorns: add a subtle savory note
- Bay leaf: delivers classic flair for seafood boils
- Ice: chills the shrimp quickly so they stay bouncy and perfectly cooked
- Fresh parsley and lemon wedges: finish the platter with restaurant style flair
- Ketchup: forms the tangy base of the classic cocktail sauce choose a variety with pure ingredients for best flavor
- Prepared horseradish: is the kick you remember from old school shrimp cocktails taste before adding more
- Lemon juice: brings zing and brightness
- Worcestershire sauce: gives umami depth look for brands without fillers
- Hot sauce: adds a gentle heat that pairs perfectly with the seafood use just a dash or skip for a milder version
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Prepare the Shrimp:
- Fill a pot with water and add lemon halves salt black peppercorns and bay leaf Bring to a gentle boil so the flavors infuse the water Carefully add the peeled deveined shrimp Stir gently and watch closely After about two or three minutes the shrimp will curl and turn pink and opaque This means they are perfectly cooked so do not let them go any further or they will get rubbery
- Chill the Shrimp:
- Once the shrimp are done scoop them out of the boiling water and drop them straight into a bowl of ice and water This ice bath immediately halts the cooking process keeping the shrimp juicy Let them cool for five to ten minutes then drain them well Pat dry so no extra water dilutes the flavor or texture
- Make the Cocktail Sauce:
- In a small bowl combine ketchup horseradish freshly squeezed lemon juice Worcestershire and a little hot sauce if using Stir together until blended well Taste and adjust the horseradish or lemon if you prefer more tang Chill the sauce until ready to serve so it is thick and bright
- Assemble the Cocktail:
- Fill a cocktail or martini glass with crushed ice Arrange the chilled shrimp neatly around the rim so they are easy to grab Place a bowl of the cocktail sauce in the center or set it in the glass Garnish the platter or glass with lemon wedges and a leafy sprig of fresh parsley for a party ready look
Save
One of my favorite parts is picking out plump pink shrimp from the ring and dragging it through the cold spicy sauce I always remember how my mom arranged them just so every holiday and now I keep the tradition alive
Storage Tips
Store extra shrimp in a sealed container in the fridge and use within two days Keep the cocktail sauce separate so the shrimp do not get soggy If the shrimp have been sitting out for longer than an hour especially over ice it is best to eat them right away for food safety
Ingredient Substitutions
If you are out of horseradish a bit of Dijon mustard and freshly grated ginger can mimic that signature zing You can swap out Worcestershire for a dash of soy sauce or skip it for a simpler sauce For an even fancier touch try adding a spoonful of chili sauce to the cocktail mix
Serving Suggestions
Serve shrimp cocktail as an elegant appetizer at holiday tables summer gatherings or even as a light lunch with a crisp green salad For parties arrange the shrimp and sauce on a large platter with fresh herbs and extra lemon so guests can help themselves Shrimp cocktail is also great as a brunch starter when paired with a sparkling drink
Cultural and Historical Context
Shrimp cocktail reached its height of popularity at midcentury American steak houses but its roots actually go further back to early 20th century banquets The bright red sauce and chilled seafood made it a mark of elegance for special occasions and today it gives a classic retro finish to any meal
Recipe FAQs
- → How do you keep the shrimp tender?
Poach shrimp briefly in gently boiling seasoned water, then immediately transfer to an ice bath to halt cooking. This ensures a tender and juicy texture.
- → What gives the cocktail sauce its signature flavor?
The combination of ketchup and horseradish creates a tangy, spicy base, with lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, and a dash of hot sauce adding depth and brightness.
- → Why include lemon and bay leaf in the cooking water?
Lemon and bay leaf infuse the shrimp with subtle aromatics and a hint of citrus, enhancing their natural sweetness.
- → Can this appetizer be prepared in advance?
Yes, the shrimp and sauce can be prepared ahead and chilled separately. Assemble with ice just before serving for the best texture.
- → How should the dish be presented?
Arrange shrimp around a glass rim filled with crushed ice, placing the sauce at the center, then garnish with lemon wedges and parsley for a striking look.